Lie to You Read online

  Lie to You

  USA Today Bestselling Author

  J.C. VALENTINE

  Books by

  J.C. VALENTINE

  Night Calls

  Stranded

  That First Kiss

  Surrender to Love

  Trust

  Wayward Fighters

  Knockout

  Tapout

  Blue Collar

  Sweetest Temptations

  Forbidden

  Dance for Me

  ABOUT THIS BOOK

  What if the person who stole your heart wasn't who you thought they were?

  When my parents passed away, I grew up fast. Learning to stand on my own two feet has been a challenge, but I'm making it... my way. I make no apologies for the path I've chosen. My choices have served me well, but no one knows the real me.

  Except one man.

  He's a mystery to me. He's controlling, demanding, and he has me wrapped around his little finger. Anything he wants, I'll give it to him. The hours we share together aren't about love. It's just sex. Hot, dirty, passionate sex. It was never supposed to be anything more than that.

  Until everything changed.

  Now, I'm more confused than ever. The more I learn about him, the less I seem to understand. What I do know is that I'm falling, and I have the feeling when I land, it's going to hurt.

  For you, my loyal readers.

  ONE

  I’m going to kill myself. Okay, maybe nothing that drastic. Still, I need a distraction in the worst way. If I sit in this apartment any longer, doing nothing but watching Netflix movies and talking to myself, I’m going to lose my freaking mind.

  It’s been three days since I walked out of Ransom’s apartment. Unfortunately, walking out of his life hasn’t been as easy. Just as before, when we decided that seeing each other wasn’t the best idea we ever had, I can’t escape him. It’s impossible to do when I have to see him every single day in class, though.

  To make matters worse, it’s clear that he and his brother, Rebel, don’t intend to leave me alone. If it’s not the constant looks preventing me from concentrating on my classwork, then it’s the constant, salacious looks following me around inside the club.

  My life is hell.

  Which is why I have decided to lock myself away at home at the end of the day. I need the peace. I need the space. From everything and everyone. Ever since I found out I was sleeping with twin brothers, it feels like my life has turned into a whirlwind of chaos.

  Okay, maybe not chaos. Christ, even my thoughts are prone to melodrama today. I can’t even begin to express how much I don’t need the added drama in my life right now.

  Annie is my only source of companionship at the moment, but with her gearing up to move clear across the country in a matter of days, even she can’t give me as much of her time as I need. As much as I enjoy catching up on the latest season of Teen Wolf, I’m not used to staying indoors so long and am in major need of a change in environment. It’s Sunday night and I’m in the mood for fun.

  Flicking off the television, I drop the remote on the table and reach for the phone. There is one person I can always count on when I need to blow off some steam.

  “Helloooooo!” Brody’s deep, craggy voice barrels down the line and I have to hold the phone away from my ear to avoid going prematurely deaf. There are all kinds of racket going on in the background, which confirms my belief that he was the right person to call.

  “Hey, are you busy tonight?”

  “J, baby, what’s up?”

  Warmth spreads over me and I smile to myself at his pet name and the enthusiasm in which he speaks it. “I need to get out of the house. I’m going stir crazy over here.”

  A girl screams somewhere in the background and the music grows even louder. “Shit, I can’t hear a thing. Hold on a sec. Let me find someplace quiet.”

  I wait patiently, listening as the noise levels steadily decrease and then disappear altogether. When Brody speaks again, his voice is a little heavier than normal as if he is out breath. “Okay, we’re alone now.”

  “Did you just run up the stairs?”

  “I did,” he says, a smile in his voice. “And even though you didn’t ask, I think it’s important to tell you I am alone, in a stranger’s bedroom, and…I just laid down. You should also know that these blankets are ridiculously soft. I think they might be Egyptian.”

  “Really,” I chuckle. “Is there anything else I should know? Like why you’re lying in a stranger’s bed?”

  “Yes,” he says, his voice growing husky. “I’m touching myself.”

  “Brody!”

  He laughs, the sound rich and smooth, and it makes the smile I’m already wearing stretch across my face. “You’re too easy. So, what’s up?”

  Sobering, I say, “I’m bored. I was wondering if it’d be cool if I hang out with you tonight. Unless it will get in the way of you scoring. Lord knows, I never want to be accused of cock blocking.”

  He chuckles again. “You’re always welcome to hang out. You know this. So what time are you coming, or do you need a lift?”

  I look out the open window in my living room. It’s after dark. Living as close to the campus as I do, it makes it easy to walk the short distance to any major party being thrown. Despite all that, I find that I am a little nervous tonight. Not of the dark, but of who I might run into.

  “Umm...”

  “Say no more,” Brody cuts me off. “I’m on my way.”

  Apparently, I took too long responding. He hangs up before I can say any more and I sigh as I end the call. It disgusts me how needy I’m being. Normally, I try only to rely on myself. That way, I’m never indebted to anyone. But Brody’s giving nature makes it easy to let my guard down. He’s like a big brother, always looking out for me, always coming to my rescue. It makes it difficult to keep things platonic between us.

  Brody is sexy. He’s a tough jock on the field and a playboy off it. His dark hair and eyes combined with his unfailing confidence makes him a total catch. This is what he projects to everyone, but I’m the only one who gets to see his soft, sensitive side.

  Recently, Annie insisted that he was in love with me. I know she’s right. I also know how lucky I would be to have him. On paper, Brody is the perfect guy. But the problem is that I don’t want him like that. At one time, I thought I could change those feelings, but it’s just never going to happen.

  Right now, my head is plenty full trying to figure out what to do with the two men currently in my life. I don’t need any added complications. Brody and I are friends, and that’s it.

  I hear footsteps bounding up the stairs and a moment later, a heavy fist bangs against it three times. It’s Brody’s signature knock, and as I stand up to answer the door, I look down at my zebra-print pajama bottoms and fluffy slippers and realize I’ve done absolutely nothing with myself today.

  “Shit.” Well, there’s nothing to be done about it now. Shuffling over to the door, I remove the chain and turn the lock. The door is already opening before I can reach for the handle, and then Brody is stepping inside.

  He takes one look at my clothing and smirks. “It’s not a sleepover, baby girl.”

  I roll my eyes as I walk away, letting him take care of the door. “I forgot to change. Just give me a minute to pull myself together and we can go.”

  One of the benefits of staying home is that I’ve been able to keep up with my laundry. As in, I’ve actually managed to put it away. It feels strange to stand inside my closet looking at neatly arranged clothes instead of rummaging through the mountain I usually dump on the floor. I have to admit, it makes the process much easier.

  Spotting a cobalt blue maxi dress, I tug it from the hanger and select a pair of tall black pumps to go with it. Laying
the dress out on my bed, I pull my pajamas off and kick them away. Giddy anticipation fills me as I step into the clingy material. Tonight, I want to get wasted and forget the last couple days—hell, the last few months—ever happened.

  After dusting on some blush and glossing my lips, I pull my hair back into a high ponytail. I perform a final inspection in the mirror and smile. I love this dress. It makes me appear taller and curvier than I really am and the color compliments my eyes.

  Scooping up my shoes, I head back into the living room. “Give the lady an award,” I announce proudly. “I do believe I just set a record for getting ready.”

  My feet slow as I catch sight of Brody on my couch. His big body is sprawled sideways across the length of it, one leg propped on an armrest, an arm dangling off the side. At the opposite end of the couch, his head his nestled in a tangerine satin throw pillow, his features slack.

  “Are you serious?” I smile and laugh as I approach, expecting him to jump up any second. But the closer I get, the more my smile falls. “This is a joke, right? You’re not actually sleeping, are you?”

  Reaching his side, I bend down and press my hand to his hard pec. Then I shake him violently. He doesn’t move an inch.

  Frowning, I decide to wait him out in case he really is playing a trick on me. But as the minutes tick by and he begins to snore softly, I realize he’s not getting up.

  My heart falls a little in disappointment, taking my good mood with it. Well, that’s that. Looks like another night stuck inside.

  “Joy.”

  Setting my shoes on the table, I lean over Brody and untuck the blanket trapped under his legs. It takes some work, but I finally manage to free it, and then I drape it over him. He’s sleeping like the dead, which I guess is good for him. Between the hours he puts in at school, at work, and on the field, I’m sure he needs it.

  Grabbing the remote, I curl up in the chair across from him and aim it at the television. As I sign back into Netflix, I figure maybe I will get to catch up on Teen Wolf after all.

  TWO

  I finish my set and walk backstage to the dressing room. It’s Monday. I didn’t expect to see Rebel on the floor again tonight, but he was, and I can’t shake the look in his eyes as he watched me dance. It’s hard to explain, but something about it makes my skin feel hypersensitive.

  My mood is still dark following last night’s bust. After Brody had fallen asleep, I binged on old episodes of Vampire Diaries and Teen Wolf. Hey, a girl’s got to find escape where she can, and television shows packed full of hot guys isn’t a bad way to do it, but it wasn’t enough to erase this funk I’ve found myself in.

  The tug of war going on inside my head feels like a boulder, pinning me down with its weight. Despite how much I hate feeling this way, seeing Rebel out there tonight only increases my urgency to get back home and hide under a blanket.

  Once I’m dressed in my street clothes—a pair of dark jeans and three-quarter sleeve billowing black V-neck blouse with a cinched waist—I hurry toward my car like my ass is on fire. I don’t want to talk to him tonight. Or any night, for that matter.

  Just the thought of it causes me to break out in a sweat.

  Leaping into the front seat, I lock the doors with one hand and turn the car on with the other. I don’t breathe right until the car is in motion.

  It’s as I am backing out of my parking spot that I glance up to see the back emergency exit door swing open. The lighting out here is terrible, but I can tell by the height and bulk of the person who steps out that it’s Rebel.

  He’s looking for me. His head swings around and I can tell the instant he spots my car. His face is cast in heavy shadows, but his body language is stiff and menacing. He takes a step forward, and I feel a flare of panic in my gut.

  Pressing my foot on the accelerator, I speed toward the main street. The path takes me right past where he is standing, and as I get closer, I am finally able to see him clearly.

  Hard anger burns in his dark eyes as I pass by. I cringe and focus all my attention straight ahead. It’s a coward’s move, I know. But I don’t have the first clue how to handle any of this.

  Dating two brothers at once is bad enough. Wanting them both is even worse. Even if I was to choose, there’s no guarantee either of them still want me back. Rebel’s and my relationship was purely superficial, and I have no idea where Ransom and I were headed. It felt like we were building up to something, but now he won’t even speak to me. Or I won’t speak to him. All of this is making my head swim. Whatever. Not talking is fine with me. I need the space and time to clear my head.

  The only thing that concerns me right now is finding out what Rebel wants from me. Clearly, it’s something, or he wouldn’t keep showing up at my job. Thankfully, he doesn’t know much else about me. Unless Ransom tells him where I live, my home is still a safe haven.

  I regret the thought the instant I pull up in front of my apartment. What is this, stalk Josephine night?

  The sleek silver BMW would catch anyone’s eye, but parked beside older model cars driven by fellow students, it sticks out like a sore thumb.

  I’d know that car anywhere. I looked under its hood once, but the car isn’t what stuck in my head. It was the owner.

  Ransom is here. Ten to one says he’s waiting for me, and I have to ask myself who or what I’ve pissed off to earn this kind of punishment. Can’t these men just leave me alone?

  My legs tremble as I step out of the car and walk the few steps to the building. I live on the second floor, first door on the right, so when I walk through the entrance, I see Ransom right away. He’s sitting on the top step just outside my door. His head his bowed, his black hair gleaming under the overhead lights, one knee bent up to his chest with the opposite foot resting two stairs below.

  I pause, my nerves growing exponentially, and just watch him there. He looks so relaxed like he’s been waiting awhile.

  I step further inside, letting the door close behind me. At the soft whoosh, Ransom lifts his head. His eyes are dull at first, but they brighten as he looks me over. I don’t know what he’s seeing, but the way he eyes me makes me tingle all over.

  I take the first few steps hesitantly, my pace quickening as I continue to climb. Ransom gets to his feet as I reach the top, and stands aside to let me pass.

  I’m not about to go inside. Ransom never gave me back my key, so I am hyper aware that he could let himself in whenever he wants. But he hasn’t yet, so I have to believe that he won’t push the issue now.

  I think of asking for my key back, but my voice seems to be stuck in my throat. I don’t know what to say, so I croak out a simple, “Hey.”

  “Hey.” Ransom’s stern countenance eases into a soft smile as he stares down at me. His expression rocks me, and I look away, twisting my keys around my finger. It’s a nervous gesture that totally gives me away, but he doesn’t comment on it.

  The pressure to say something builds between us like a tangible thing, charging the air. My eyes dart around the empty hallway as the tension continues to grow, and, inside my head, a little voice screams at me to say something. Mercifully, Ransom speaks first.

  “I didn’t mean to ambush you. I’m sure I’m the last person you want to see right now,” he rumbles. “I’ve been turning this over in my head for days, how this was going to go. I wasn’t even sure I would come. But I honestly didn’t know how I couldn’t. I mean, this isn’t how I’d pictured things going between us.”

  He’s rambling. Somehow, in all this fucked-up craziness, Ransom’s rambling breaks through the mental block I’ve been trying to build since the confrontation between me, him, and his brother at their apartment better than a pick through ice. I find myself amused by this, a faint smile growing on my lips as he continues on.

  “Caring about someone is supposed to be simple. Simple is good. I like simple. But this—” he motions a finger between us “—is the farthest thing from simple you can get.”

  I nod, because, yeah, I know.
Who knows better than me? I’m the girl standing between two brothers. I’m the girl who’s wrecking lives. I’m that girl I enjoy watching on reality television.

  The smile slips. My life has fallen to shit and I don’t know how the hell I managed to get here, but I can tell you now, it was an honest mistake. How in the hell was I supposed to know there were two of them? People talk about having doppelgangers, evil twins, what-have-you, but who really puts stock into it?

  “I mean, I should have known something was going on, right? I should have sensed something was off.” Ransom is gesticulating all over the place and I have a feeling I know where this is headed.

  I cut him off, unwilling to go down that road tonight. “I’m going to stop you there,” I say, holding up my hand. Catching him mid-sentence, he pauses, his mouth frozen open. “I’ve been on my feet all night. I’m tired and hungry and I’m not in the mood to hash this out with you right now.”

  “That’s the problem, though, isn’t it?” Ransom questions. His agitated tone sets me on edge. “When will you be ready to talk about it, Josephine? Because from where I’m standing, you’re the one holding all the answers. I’m just trying to figure out how the hell this all happened.”

  I. Am. Floored. A laugh bubbles up from my throat, sounding warped, even to my ears. “I hate to break it to you, but you’re not the only one trying to figure this out. How do you think it feels to be me?” I demand, growing angrier by the second. This is exactly why I wanted to avoid this.

  “I’ve been fucking around with two men, and I couldn’t even tell the difference!” I shout, angry at myself, him, Rebel. Everyone. “Talk about humiliation. I’m just trying to figure out which one of you was in on it. Or maybe both of you were. Maybe,” I say, my voice growing too loud, “you two planned this whole thing. Seduce some naïve college girl, make her fall in love with you, then rip the rug right out from under her. Surprise! We’re goddamned twins!”